See Why People Do Repeat Business With Us
From rare coins and precious metals to jewelry, paper currency, and unique collectibles, we buy it all—big or small. Since 1999, Specialty Rarities has built lasting relationships through honesty, expert guidance, and fair market evaluations.
Our History and Our Philosophy
Specialty Rarities was founded in 1999. From the inception of the company, the main focus has always been on the client. Our philosophy is to be straightforward, provide as much information and education as the client wants. To be consistent, to be fair, and treat others like you yourself would want to be treated.
We have a long history of not just satisfied customers, but literally customers that have been with us for many decades. No question is unimportant, and the only thing that is important about your collection is what is good for you and your family.
Explore Our Coins Buying Services
Gold & Silver Bullion Coins
We buy and sell gold and silver bullion coins at fair market value, offering honest appraisals and top payouts for your precious metals.
US Silver Coins
We purchase all U.S. silver coins, from common to rare, offering fair market value and expert appraisals to ensure the correct valuation.
US Silver Dollars
We buy all U.S. silver dollars, from circulated to rare editions, providing honest appraisals and top payouts for your valuable coins.
US Paper Currency
Businesses rely on us to safeguard assets, personnel, and customers. Our guards blend into your environment
Liberty & Indian Gold Coins
Early US Silver Dollars
US Type Coins
All Foreign Coins
Coins We Buy
We buy all US, gold, silver, platinum, copper coins, from colonials to gold including territorials, patterns, & errors. We buy all foreign coins as well. We buy coins certified by NGC, CAC, PCGS, ANACS, and other grading services, and uncertified raw coins. We are member dealers of NGC and CAC. Do not hesitate to pick up the phone and call us and see why people do repeat business with us.
Call Now For Your Free, No Obligation Appraisal
Get expert evaluations and get the right value for your coins, paper currency, jewelry, and other collectibles-completely free with no pressure or obligation. We treat people the way we like to be treated.
Call to find out when our next free educational seminar is.
Hear From Our Satisfied Client
EXCELLENT Based on 73 reviews Posted on Google Crossroad Home servicesTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I went to Specialty Rarities to sell a collection of coins my mom left me. Jeff was awesome explaining every coin and it’s value more than fair with his prices If you need an honest opinion on a coin collection this is where you need to go…… I’m glad I went!! Thank you Jeff. Joy RussoPosted on Google Edward ChiusanoTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. My wife and I just left Specialty Rarities , Jeff spent over 21/2 hours going over all the coins we brought in, taking his time and explaining everything to us , we were very pleased by the end result . We met Jeff last year when he gave a seminar for Seniors at the Hicksville Library , we highly recommend him , and if he’s going to your library we suggest you check him out. EdPosted on Google John SansonettiTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jeff and Francine went out of their way to teach me the history behind the coins I have been purchasing for my collection. Jeff really knows his stuff and is a master of his craft. He also blows away his competition charging me minimal premium and even sold me some coins and bars at spot price. Highly recommended. Thank youPosted on Google Wm. BTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jeff is the owner and the last of a rare breed! I'm a tough critic with a low barometer for BS. It was a pleasure doing business with him in Precious Metals. Fair purchase prices and fair prices when selling it back to him. Lots of jerks in this business... he is among a rare group of industry business men with class! Highly recommend for a great experience and being treated fairly!Posted on Google James FlorezTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Jeff went above and beyond to service my needs. 5 star service!Posted on Google schm0tz 44Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Stopped in to sell a little bit of silver I found metal detecting. The owner was very knowledgeable and fair, the whole process was quick and easy. Will return for any precious metal related needs.Posted on Google Norbert HeuserTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Absolutely thrilled doing business with Jeff and Francine. Honest prices and eclectic treasures.Posted on Google Victoria DanielsTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. just went today with my boyfriend and i called before the owner was super nice and then once we went francine was so helpful n educated taught us a lot n gave fair prices. will be back !! you guys are the best thank u!!! ♥️Posted on Google Richard SternTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. It was an absolute pleasure to do business at Specialty Rarities! Jeff and Francine are warm, kind and welcoming people who are quite knowledgeable. Jeff was very honest and explained everything comprehensively. We had done enough research to know that they gave us an incredibly fair price for our silver. We highly recommend this trustworthy establishment as the quintessential locale for dealing in valuable metals, coins and collectibles.
Get In Touch With Us
Reach out to Specialty Rarities for expert buying and appraisals of coins, jewelry, collectibles, and antiques. Our knowledgeable team is ready to help you get the most value for your valuables.